SignReady › Blog › External confirmations (SA 505)
Audit procedures

External confirmations under SA 505: bank, debtor and creditor procedures that stand up to review

By SignReady Team · Published 19 Nov 2026 · Updated 15 Nov 2026 · 3 min read · Law as at 15 November 2026
External confirmations (SA 505) — SignReady guide
In this guide · 7 sections
  1. What the auditor needs to establish
  2. A practical procedure
  3. How to document the work
  4. Common mistakes
  5. Final review questions
  6. FAQs
  7. Sources
Key points
  • A confirmation is persuasive only when the auditor controls the request and can assess the response. A reply forwarded by management is not a substitute for direct, reliable audit evidence.
  • Plan, perform, evidence and conclude are four separate parts of a defensible audit step.
  • A clear working-paper reference and reviewer conclusion matter as much as the checklist tick.

Try SignReady: Keep the procedure, evidence and conclusion in one review-ready audit file.

Start free

A confirmation is persuasive only when the auditor controls the request and can assess the response. A reply forwarded by management is not a substitute for direct, reliable audit evidence.

What the auditor needs to establish

Start with the audit objective and the assertion at risk. A good file lets a reviewer see the population or matter examined, why the procedure was selected, what evidence was obtained, exceptions found and the conclusion reached. The steps below are a practical framework; they must be tailored to the engagement, assessed risks and applicable reporting framework.

Turn the procedure into a review-ready file

Use SignReady to keep the procedure, evidence, open query and partner conclusion together. Start with 3 finalisations free.

Start free — 3 finalisations

A practical procedure

  1. Select balances and terms to confirm based on materiality, risk, disputed balances and unusual movements—not simply the largest balances.
  2. Maintain control over the request: verify addresses, send it directly, retain the request list and record the date and method.
  3. Assess the response’s reliability, investigate exceptions, and perform alternative procedures for non-responses where required.
  4. Separate genuine timing differences from possible misstatements; document the result, follow-up and conclusion for each confirmation.

How to document the work

RecordWhat it should show
Purpose and riskThe assertion, population or issue being addressed and why the work is necessary for this client.
Work performedWho performed it, date, population/selection where relevant, documents inspected and tests completed.
Evidence and exceptionsWorking-paper references, copies or links to evidence, exceptions and follow-up.
Conclusion and reviewA clear conclusion against the objective, effect on the financial statements/report, reviewer comments and closure.

In SignReady, use the relevant programme area to attach the evidence, raise exceptions as review points and record the conclusion before final partner sign-off. That is a workflow benefit—not a substitute for professional judgement or the underlying procedures.

Common mistakes

  • Accepting client-routed replies without assessing authenticity.
  • Treating no response to a negative confirmation as positive evidence.
  • Closing an exception as “timing” without supporting documents.

Final review questions

  • Does the work respond to the specific risk, rather than a generic checklist?
  • Could another experienced auditor understand what was tested and why?
  • Are all exceptions resolved, quantified or carried into the final evaluation?
  • Does the conclusion link to the financial statements or reporting decision?

Try SignReady: Give your reviewer the workpaper reference, conclusion and open points in one place.

Start free

Frequently asked questions

Can I use this as a standard audit checklist?

Use it as a starting framework only. Tailor the objective, procedures, selection and conclusion to the entity, assessed risks and applicable standards.

What makes a working paper review-ready?

It identifies the objective, work performed, evidence, exceptions, conclusion, preparer and reviewer. A tick without that trail is rarely enough.

Can SignReady replace professional judgement?

No. SignReady organises work, evidence, review points and finalisation. The auditor remains responsible for the audit procedures, conclusions and report.

Sources

Make the review easier to complete

SignReady brings your trial balance, working papers, review points and finalisation checks into the same client file. Start free — 3 finalisations.

Start free — 3 finalisations

Audit and accounts updates, practical tips and knowledge: join the Audit and Accounts Update group on WhatsApp.

About this guide. Written by the SignReady Team at PracticeGuru (Brainy Accountant Solutions Pvt Ltd). SignReady is our product and is mentioned where it fits. The guide reflects the law and standards as at 15 November 2026 and the sources listed above. It is general information, not professional advice: check the primary sources and apply your own professional judgement to each engagement.
Version history: 19 Nov 2026 — first published. This guide is part of SignReady's audit-procedures series. It links the audit objective, procedures, evidence and conclusion so the work can be reviewed properly.